I received-- Chris cooley, Eli Manning, Correll buckholter, and marquis colston.

I gave-- Todd heap, Matt cassell, kevin Smith, and Steve Slaton


In general a good trade?? He was in need of a back i felt solid at the back position with rice and turner... any suggestions or feedback would be appreciated.. also who do u start this week Schaub against cincy or Manning against the saints???


my team looks like this now

Matt Schaub qb

Nate Burleson wr

Dwayne Bowe wr

Ray Rice RB

Michael Turner RB

Owen Daniels TE

Steve smith (carolina) WR

Devin Hester wr

Carnell Williams RB

Marques Colston WR

Chris Cooley TE

Eli Manning QB

Correll Buckhalter RB

Stephen Gostkowski K

Denvers D

If Buckhalter comes back and isn't sharing carries your good. If he is and one of your starter RBs gets hurt, you may be thin at RB.

I think its a good trade for you, even with that. You upgrade a lot, but assumed some risk. Its how you win the league, you go for it!

thanks for the input bud!... i just figure i am giving up slaton for manning...... kevin smith for buckholter, so what? cooley for heap, so what again and cooley has a way bigger upside in my opinion, and i really needed a wide out so i got colston for cassell....

It just seemed to be a no brainer... there are some what if's if there is a injury but i just couldnt pass this up

I'd try to move cadillac and buckhalter in a package for a decent rb if you can. Both of those guys are risky, I like Cooley, I'd play Manning against the saints myself

It looks like a good trade for you, and i agree with 94browns about trading.Slaton has been MIA all season and i expected big numbers from him this year.Its a gamble on who to start a qb, i like manning and the giants but the saints D has only given up 2 touchdown passes so far.