Is anyone else intrigued by Marion Barber this year?

I have the 4th pick in my keeper league. AP is someone's keeper, so assuming the first three picks are LT, Westbrook, SJax....should I go Addai or Barber?

It's a PPR league by the way.

Addai had like 41 passes last year to Barber's 44...Barber has looked like a beast in presseason while Indy just doesn't look like Indy without Manning under center...

Who would you take? Addai or Barber?

I would take Addai. I am not a fan of taking guys who haven't carried the load an entire season so high in the draft. You know Addai can produce being the #1 guy, but can Barber. I am not so sold on him, didn't he split time with Lawrence Marony is College too? Heck Lamont jordan looked like a first round type back when he left his platoon with the jets and Curtis Martin (i think). I'm just saying....


Could be dead wrong though...

I was in a similar situation with the number 6 pick....sadly I chose Addai and he's stunk it up for me so far